My usage history
Back in 2009, one of the first advantages that made me play around with Emacs again when I went back to graduate school was Emacs-Speaks-Statistics. It allowed me to avoid the pain of using the R-console which was frankly a miserable experience. The deficiencies of that interface stood in stark contrast to the enormous benefits to be had by using a FREE and open source statistical computing environment where each function could be examined and verified. Data analysis was no longer tied to a machine with a working license server. I could now work from home or even on my lengthy commute from Coney Island to school in Manhattan. Three dead hours of my day now became my most productive time. Although I do not have the resources to donate to the project I have cited it in my scientific work and encourage others who have used it to do the same.
R vs Python
Although R has continued to improve since I started using it. The Python Data community has truly blossomed, albeit from a much lower base. Tools like numpy, scipy networkx, NLTK, sympy, pandas, rpy2 and particularly IPython have made Python a formidable competitor in the scientific computing space. In fact I am not going to give links to the source code because best practice is to install them in a virtual environment using pip. The best instructions I have found for Linux are here. I will write a tutorial for Mac and Windows next week. The reason why IPython has had such a profound impact are human rather than technical. IPython prints detailed error messages where as R prints error messages that are cryptic at best. Python has a vibrant community with numerous initiatives to reach under-served, under-computed and under-represented groups including PyLadies and other-groups. R help is notoriously caustic.
Funny you should ask. Trey Causey a PhD student at University of Washington (where R. Doug Martin used to teach statistics and owned the R predecessor language S+) wrote a blog-post asking whether R-help had gotten meaner. There are 20 comments on his post and it generated a response article by Columbia’s Andrew-Gelman who has an 35,174 citations and h-index of 63. (That is 63 papers cited at least 63 times.) I took a less sophisticated approach. I read their posting-guide and answers and I vowed to never ask a question. If I want to be abused like that I will go find a job on a trading desk. But searching the archives and other sources, I got by.
I discovered the notebook from this post on R-bloggers back in November 2012. The browser was a great way to show work across various operating systems. But whoa, did this mean I actually had to edit in the browser. Christ! It was like using Word, or Notepad++. Surely we can do better. Well I couldn’t, but Takafumi Arakaki could. He made the IPython Notebook a mode in Emacs. A powerful editor, the ability to work interactively and display the results in the browser where bosses, students and PI’s feel at home. If you have not set it up, please read my tutorial. But at the Data Science for Social Good Fellowship.I am looking at data that is simply to big for my laptop. I needed to run IPython remotely on an amazon ec2 instance but edit the interactive session locally. These servers have no windowing software (x11) and it violates the terms of service to install it. There were a few choices.
- Run IPython remotely (on the instance) and edit it a local non-window version of Emacs.
- Run IPython remotely on a public ip over http. (This is a really bad idea for reasons I will explain.)
- Run IPython remotely on a public ip over SSL/TLS with a password.(A somewhat less bad idea bad idea.)
- Run IPython remotely on a port on the remote localhost, 127.0.0.1 and forward that port to our local localhost (no typo there) via ssh. Then we can pick it when we open the notebook list in Emacs. The command is M-x ein:notebooklist-open. ‘M’ here, is ‘Meta’ which on Linux or Windows is mapped to the Alt key and on Mac is mapped to the command key.
Why everything sucks but the last option.
- If you edit on the remote machine you are using Emacs inside the bash shell. Any extended key-bindings don’t work including the bindings for the emacs-ipython notebook (ein). Everytime I wanted to execute a cell I had to type
M-x ein:notebook-execute-and-goto-nextinsteand of M-RET. That sucks!
- Run IPython remotely on a public ip over http. Whoa, now we have a process listening that can execute linux commands on a shared remote computer that is completely unsecured. That sucks!
- Run IPython remotely on a public ip over SSL/TLS with a password. Ok, so this is what the IPython documentation suggests. Here is the link and you should also check out this github repo. The difference is what they name the key and certificate but the first set of instructions did not work for me while the second did. Choose a good password it probably is no worse than buying a book at Amazon. But it still leaves you editing in the browser. That sucks!
- Finally the fourth option is confusing but it gets done what we want. The important thing to understand is that we need to forward the remote machine’s local port to our localhost using -L option in ssh. The best explanation I could find is here in the section on Forwarding Local Ports to Remote. This is hard, but it does not suck!
Start on your machine. Set up a .ssh/config file where you define the host and identity. Good directions are here. It is worth stating, the local machine is your laptop and the remote is the server you are using. The result is that establishing an ssh connection should be as easy as:
- Here is a sample config file based on my own. This will not work on your machine.
Configure ein. See my issue on the ein repo to set your
ein:console argsI set up a profile locally rather than used sshfs as Takafumi suggested. The directions are in this repo. If you are using a virtual environment, the configuration will be in:
Make a directory on the remote machine to put your notebook files. Start the server normally.
ipython notebook –pylab=inline –no-browser –port=6000
From another terminal on your local machine:
ssh -N -f -L 7000:127.0.0.1:6000 myServer
- Open emacs. Type:
M-x ein:notebooklist-open. When Emacs asks which port say 7000.
Congratulations, you now have an ssh connection to your notebook on a remote server in local emacs. And you know what, that my friend, does not suck at all.
You can download the R-language by following this R-link and Vincent Goulet generously makes Emacs with ESS available through his website for both Mac OS X and Windows.